
This question was addressed by Brandon Funston of Yahoo, and he came to the conclusion that A-Rod was the top choice. And I have to say, I agree with this.
Both players are basically in their prime. A-Rod's older, but he's not slowing down any. Funston makes a point to mention lineups, and this is a good point... do you want Johnny Damon and Derek Jeter hitting in front of you or David Eckstein and Junior Spivey? A-Rod should have more RBI opportunities.
But the biggest factor, I think, is their positions. Yes, there are some good, young 3B (David Wright is a stud already, and I believe Migeul Cabrera is moving back to 3B this year), but on the whole, hitting is easier to find from a 1B than a 3B. And this is what set A-Rod apart in my book.
Conclusion: Pujols is the better hitter, A-Rod is the better fantasy value.
No comments:
Post a Comment